Book of the Moment: “The Moral Instruments” Trilogy
The Moral Instruments Trilogy: City of Bone, City of Ashes, City of Glass by Cassandra Clare
Began: Christmas 2009
Finished: Spring 2010
I’ve got to be honest with you, I read a lot of reviews for this trilogy. Back in Christmas 2009, this was one of the more popular sells, and being the contrary soul I am, I sought negative reviews on Amazon and Goodreads.
Major complaints included shades of Star Wars, Buffy the Vampire Slayers, and Harry Potter. After reading the first book, I could pick out the Star Wars and a bit of Harry Potter (it seems that any fantasy novel will immediately be compared to HP, won’t it?), but I’ve only watched the first season of Buffy, so I can’t say for certain if Clare did borrow from the show. (And frankly, I don’t plan on watching any more; it’s just not my thing. Yeah, yeah, go weep to your god, Joss Whedon fans.)
I’ve also heard stories about Clare from the HP fandom. Nasty stories about plagiarism lying. Yes, she was a fanfic writer, and one of the few to make it to the bestseller lists, if I’m not mistaking.
I picked it up anyway.
And I liked it. Not enough to become a raving fan, but just enough to buy the whole paperback set and keep it on my bookshelf. And the covers are pretty, too. (I’ve downloaded wallpaper for my laptop.)
Clare can spin a gorgeous sentence, and there were a few instances where I felt envious of her talent. But what pissed me off were the characters. You have a group of elitist, isolationists called the Shadowhunters–the Big Damn Heroes–who have been entrusted by The Great Angel Whose Name I’ve Conveniently Forgotten with protecting the human race and all the mystical people in between. Thing is, they don’t like humans. They call them Mundies, which sounds more adorable than derogatory. Their attitude seems to be, “Oh, hell, why do we even bother? This is such a bore. Everyone that isn’t us sucks. But we must uphold justice because the Angel told us. GODDAMNED HUMAN COCKROACHES!” These aren’t heroes I want to cheer on. These are characters I want to fall–and fall fucking hard.
But Clary did endear to me, despite not being totally fleshed out. I absolutely loved Jocelyn and Luke, and cheered them on to the end. Magnus was a hoot, and I eventually did warm up to Alec. But my favorite character has to be Simon. God, poor Simon. He gets a raw deal in all three books, making him prime Butt Monkey material. I just hope the fourth book is kinder to him.
As for the love triangle… didn’t believe it. I didn’t believe in the couple that eventually rose from the confusion. I don’t care for Jace. He’s a dick, and I’m glad that Sebastian chewed him out in the third book. It was only for a few sentences, but gods, I was clapping.
All in all, they’re decent reads. Nothing monumental, no matter what the bestseller lists say. But I plan on keeping the books, and reading the fourth one and the prequel trilogy.
Now for something you might find funny: I plan on reading the original trilogy again this Christmas. I’ll admit that there are warm, pleasant memories attached to these books as I started reading them during one of the best holidays I’ve had in years. So there’s my reason.
As for Clare, I think she has talent. It’ll take a while to hone it, but I believe that she’ll be able to turn out some fantastic fiction in the coming years.
But that’s just me.





